Boat Drinks

Rum Before the Rings

Our Wedding Day

The White Room

Ceremony

Reception

Late Night Libations

Farewell Lunch

The After-After Party

Our Wedding

Our Story

Jay and Tayler’s journey began at Flagler College, in a Media Ethics class where fate—or perhaps their infamous friend Charlie DiMaria—brought them together. Tayler, ever the diligent student, sat at the front of the class, while Jay preferred the view from the back. But as the weeks went by, something magical happened. Slowly but surely, they began to move closer to each other, one seat at a time. By the time they found themselves side by side, it was clear that something special had blossomed. And from that moment on, they knew their story was just beginning.

General Information

RSVP and Attendance

Travel and Accommodation

Ceremony and Reception Details

Gifts and Registry

Miscellaneous

Q + A

In addition to the hotels listed below, we also recommend checking out Airbnb or other vacation rentals. There are plenty of great options in the area, and it may be a more cost-effective or convenient choice, especially for groups or longer stays.

Located Downtown St. Augustine

Casa Monica Resort & Spa

Casablanca Inn on the Bay

DoubleTree by Hilton Hotel

Hilton Historic Bayfront

Best Western Historical Inn

Located on Vilano Beach

Hampton Inn & Suites

Magic Beach Motel

Located on Anastasia Island

Embassy Suites Oceanfront Resort

Courtyard by Marriott

Guy Harvey Resort

Travel

Things to Do in St. Augustine

The Historic District

St. Augustine’s Historic District is the heart of the city, filled with cobblestone streets, charming colonial architecture, and historic landmarks. You can explore local shops, art galleries, and restaurants tucked into centuries-old buildings. Don’t miss out on seeing the Oldest Wooden Schoolhouse and taking in the rich history that makes this city so unique.

Castillo de San Marcos

Built in the 17th century by the Spanish, this national monument is the oldest masonry fort in the continental U.S. It’s a must-see for history buffs, with its well-preserved walls, cannons, and engaging historical reenactments. The fort offers stunning views of the Matanzas River, and you can explore its many rooms and learn about its role in defending the city during colonial times.

St. Augustine Lighthouse & Maritime Museum

This iconic lighthouse, built in 1874, offers one of the best panoramic views in St. Augustine after a climb of 219 steps. At the top, you’ll be rewarded with sweeping vistas of the city, the beaches, and the Atlantic Ocean. The maritime museum showcases the area’s rich seafaring history, complete with shipwreck artifacts, and often hosts educational events for visitors of all ages.

St. George Street

A pedestrian-only thoroughfare, St. George Street is the perfect place for a leisurely stroll. It’s lined with unique boutiques, souvenir shops, historic buildings, and cafes where you can relax and enjoy the local flavor. The vibrant atmosphere, street performers, and the chance to grab a delicious treat from a local bakery make this spot a favorite among visitors.

Flagler College

Originally the luxurious Ponce de Leon Hotel, Flagler College is a masterpiece of Spanish Renaissance architecture. Built by railroad tycoon Henry Flagler in 1888, it features beautiful stained glass windows by Louis Comfort Tiffany and stunning interior designs. Guided tours are available to showcase the college’s history and the lavish lifestyle of its original guests. This is also where we both went to college and met in our Media Law class!

Lightner Museum

Housed in the historic Alcazar Hotel, the Lightner Museum is an elegant destination for art lovers. Its collection features fine and decorative arts from the 19th and early 20th centuries, including sculptures, paintings, and antique furnishings. The museum is a peaceful escape, with its beautiful courtyards and the impressive indoor pool, which now serves as a restaurant.

The Alligator Farm Zoological Park

Home to a vast collection of reptiles, this zoological park is more than just alligators. It’s also home to crocodiles, exotic birds, and various other wildlife. You can watch feeding shows, see rare albino alligators, and even zip-line over the park’s exhibits. This family-friendly spot combines education with excitement, making it a fun stop for all ages.

Fountain of Youth Archaeological Park

Step back in time at the site where Ponce de Leon is said to have searched for the mythical Fountain of Youth. The park offers interactive exhibits on Native American history, early Spanish settlers, and archaeological finds. You can even drink from the legendary spring and enjoy live cannon and musket firings in this historical and entertaining outdoor museum.

St. Augustine Distillery

For those who enjoy craft spirits, the St. Augustine Distillery offers free tours and tastings. Located in a restored ice plant from the early 1900s, this local distillery produces high-quality small-batch vodka, gin, rum, and bourbon. Learn about the distilling process, then sample their award-winning spirits in craft cocktails at the tasting room.

San Sebastian Winery

A must-visit for wine enthusiasts, San Sebastian Winery offers free tours that explain the wine-making process, from grape to bottle. You can sample a variety of their locally produced wines, including port and sherry, and browse the gift shop for wine-themed souvenirs. The winery also features a rooftop bar with live music on weekends, where you can relax with a glass of wine and enjoy views of the city.

St. Augustine Pirate & Treasure Museum

This museum is home to one of the largest collections of authentic pirate artifacts in the world. With interactive exhibits and real pirate treasures, it offers a hands-on experience for both kids and adults. Learn about famous pirates like Blackbeard, see historical weapons, and explore the world of piracy through immersive displays.

The Old Jail Museum

Built in 1891, the Old Jail housed some of St. Augustine’s most notorious criminals. Take a guided tour led by costumed actors who bring the stories of the past to life. You’ll see the original cells, learn about the harsh conditions inmates endured, and hear fascinating tales of crime and punishment from the city’s early days.

Ripley’s Believe It or Not! Museum

If you’re looking for something a bit quirky, Ripley’s Believe It or Not! Museum offers an eccentric collection of oddities and curiosities from around the world. Housed in a historic castle, this museum features strange artifacts, interactive exhibits, and eye-popping displays that will both surprise and entertain visitors of all ages.

Things to Do

Wedding Party

Bridesmaids

Ryan Cariero - Matron of HonorSydney CarieroSophia CastilloChloe CastilloEmilee Castillo﻿Olivia RogersMegan Steadman

Groomsmen

Dylan Cariero - Best ManSeth CarieroCharlie DiMariaChris Eckard﻿Cole GarretsonBrody GordonDylan Tusinac

Flower Girls & Escorts

Leona CarieroEvelyn GarretsonSilas GarretsonChase Garretson

A New Chapter in Our Story

We are overjoyed to share some exciting news - our family has grown! We welcomed a sweet baby girl on June 23rd, and she’s already filled our lives with so much love and happiness. As we celebrate our marriage with all of you in January, we’re also looking forward to the beautiful journey of parenthood ahead. Our little Jemma Marie Cariero has made our love story even more complete, and we can't wait for her to meet all the incredible people who mean so much to us. Thank you for being part of this special time in our lives. We’re truly blessed to have your love and support! Love,Tayler, Jay &amp; Jemma

Tayler & Jonathan

Tayler & Jonathan

Our Next Chapter

A New Chapter in Our Story